“Ocean was not compromised. Our systems operated normally. We had no involvement in the incident,” the company said.
The statement follows accusations by Bitcoin developer and former Ocean chairman Luke Dashjr, who alleged that the mining pool knowingly facilitated payments to the attackers and collected fees from mining activity linked to the breach.
Ocean did not directly name Dashjr or address the specific figures he cited. Instead, its response focused on the principles governing its payout system, arguing that blocking or redirecting rewards for valid mining work would undermine Bitcoin’s permissionless nature.
“Bitcoin is either permissionless or it is not. There is no middle ground,” Ocean declared.
Ocean Says Valid Mining Work Cannot Be Reassigned
At the center of Ocean’s defense is its TIDES payout system, which the company says automatically accounts for valid proof of work and distributes mining rewards directly to participants without requiring them to surrender custody of their funds. According to Ocean, the system verifies the validity of submitted mining work but does not determine whether the submitting party owns the mining equipment or was authorized to configure it.
“We verify the work submitted, but not who owns the machines or whether someone was authorized to configure them,” Ocean explained.
The company added that once valid work has been submitted, the corresponding credit cannot be reassigned under its payout rules. Although the mining activity may have originated from equipment redirected without its owners’ consent, Ocean argues that its system is designed to process valid work according to predetermined rules rather than make discretionary judgments about who should receive the associated rewards.
Ocean further argued that allowing a mining pool to selectively block or redirect payouts would introduce centralized control over miners’ earnings.
“Permissionless mining isn’t a loophole. It’s a principle,” the company said.
It added that a pool capable of arbitrarily deciding whose valid work counts, who receives payment, or when established rules apply would require miners to trust the operator with powers Bitcoin was designed to eliminate.
Dashjr Alleged Ocean Profited From Attack
Ocean’s explanation comes after Dashjr accused the company of financially benefiting from the hijacking of Luxor customers’ mining operations. In his post, Dashjr claimed that Ocean had instructed participating miners to direct 0.16202083 $BTC, valued at approximately $10,510 at the time, to the attackers in two instances after the incident became public.
He further alleged that the pool was continuing to allocate rewards equivalent to 0.08123485 $BTC, or approximately $5,270, to the attackers and that its website indicated plans for another 0.33029017 $BTC, worth roughly $21,400, in subsequent distributions.
Dashjr also claimed Ocean had already collected 0.00330655 $BTC, valued at approximately $210, in fees associated with the compromised mining activity and stood to receive another 0.0066058034 $BTC, or approximately $440. Together, the amounts would total nearly 0.01 $BTC, worth approximately $650 at the prices cited by Dashjr.
“Yes, that’s right: Ocean is profiting from a cyberattack on their own customers, and rewarding the attackers,” Dashjr wrote.
Ocean Points to Risks of Centralized Mining Infrastructure
Beyond defending its payout mechanism, Ocean used the incident to highlight what it described as the risks of centralized mining infrastructure.
According to the company, the unauthorized redirection of Luxor’s hashrate demonstrates the vulnerabilities miners face when they delegate operational control of their equipment to third-party software providers.
“This incident underscores a fundamental risk of centralized mining: When you entrust control to a third party, you also inherit the risks of that third party’s systems,” Ocean said.
Ocean also expressed sympathy for affected miners and pledged to cooperate with Luxor, law enforcement, and customers investigating the attack. The company urged miners to secure access to their equipment, update security measures, and monitor their mining configurations for unauthorized changes.