Together, those assets made up 24% of Tether’s reserves as of September 30, 2025. A year earlier, the figure was 17%.
Bitcoin is where the math gets tight. According to S&P’s analysis, Bitcoin accounted for about 5.6% of $USDT in circulation. Tether’s overcollateralization buffer, the cushion of extra reserves above what it owes holders, was around 3.9%.
If the Bitcoin slice of the reserves fell sharply, the loss could be larger than the spare can cover. In that case, the reserves backing $USDT could end up worth less than the tokens outstanding.
Disclosure was the second problem. S&P pointed to continuing gaps in information about custodians, counterparties and the exact makeup of the reserve assets.
The previous score of “4 (constrained)” dated to December 2023. In roughly two years, Tether slid one notch on S&P’s scale while its riskier holdings grew as a share of the pile.
Tether’s response and the market backdrop
Tether did not accept the verdict quietly. The company disputed the report, arguing that S&P relied on an outdated framework. According to Tether, that framework ignores $USDT’s resilience, its transparency and a track record of holding its peg over the past decade.
Tether also points out that most of its reserves sit in short-term US Treasuries and cash equivalents. S&P’s concern sits with the minority slice, which has been getting bigger.
The size of that minority matters because $USDT is enormous. Circulation stood at about $184 billion around the time of the downgrade. Since then, it has moved between $175 billion and $180 billion.
Even after the downgrade, $USDT has kept trading near $1.
How S&P scores stablecoins
S&P’s stablecoin assessment process dates to 2023. It rates factors such as asset quality and regulatory oversight to judge how likely a token is to hold its peg.
The comparison with Circle is hard to ignore. S&P has given USDC a “strong” assessment, which puts the two biggest dollar stablecoins at opposite ends of the agency’s scale.
What this means
The Bitcoin-versus-buffer gap is the number worth tracking. If Tether shrinks its Bitcoin exposure or builds a bigger overcollateralization cushion, the most specific part of S&P’s critique loses force. If Bitcoin keeps growing as a share of reserves while the buffer stays near 3.9%, the gap gets harder to defend.