In stark contrast, traditional finance reported on the raise with more detail and none of this bullishness.
Barron’s, for example, led with “MicroStrategy’s New Preferred Issue Yields 10% as Stock Sells at Discount.”
Careful observers, rather than simply accepting the news of an oversubscribed financing round, calculated far more sobering numbers than crypto publications.
Although MicroStrategy’s headline of $584 million certainly indicated plenty of demand from investors, experienced investors know that there is always unlimited demand for an investment with excellent terms.
Read more: MicroStrategy wanted bitcoin rule change — not billions in tax bills
MicroStrategy offered a 20% discount on liquidation preference
In its press release, MicroStrategy admits that it intends to settle a public offering of 8% dividend-yielding stock with a liquidation preference of $100 per share, yet it offered those shares at $80 apiece. In other words, the company didn’t have enough demand to sell that quantity at $85, $90, or $95 per share.
Liquidation preference is the right to receive money back first — a “preference” before other equity owners — in the event of a “liquidity” (payout) event such as acquisition, public offering, or dividend.
Instead of a smaller and more advantageously priced share sale, MicroStrategy offered investors a substantial 20% discount on their liquidation preference in order to raise a larger quantity of money.
There’s never a free lunch on Wall Street. Sure, MicroStrategy will now have over half a billion dollars in extra cash to buy BTC in February. However, the capital came at a cost: a 20% liquidation preference discount, and more dilutive convertibles overhanging on common, MicroStrategy shareholders.
Whether that’s bullish or bearish news depends on the frame. Michael Saylor had to offer a discount on dividend-yielding preferreds, yet he raised a bunch of money in the process.
For what it’s worth, today’s pre-market trading session for MSTR was relatively unchanged from Thursday’s pre-announcement close.