Bitcoin faces a problem that stronger cryptography alone cannot solve: moving millions of coins to quantum-resistant security while upgrading the exchanges, custodians and bridges that handle them.
Some blockchains have begun introducing quantum-resistant security. NEAR added post-quantum transaction signing in July, while Algorand introduced native Falcon-1024 accounts in August.
Millions of bitcoin BTC$60,649.73 remain in wallets secured by older signatures, and exchanges, custodians and bridges would need to make their own changes to protect the funds they handle.
“The clock that matters is migration,” said Leo Fan, CEO of blockchain infrastructure company Cysic.
For bitcoin holders, moving funds to stronger security may become necessary long before quantum computers can break existing signatures. But dormant coins could remain exposed, and institutions holding or transferring bitcoin would have to upgrade their systems as well.
Exposed public keys
More than 6 million bitcoin, representing 31.2% of circulating supply, were held behind public keys already visible onchain in October, according to Glassnode data.
Those coins are safe for now, but a quantum computer powerful enough to break today's cryptography could use exposed public keys to gain control of the funds.
The figures illustrate the size of the migration challenge. They do not establish how many coins are lost, dormant or impossible to move.
Bitcoin developers are already debating what should happen to holdings that fail to migrate.
In April, developer Jameson Lopp and five co-authors proposed Bitcoin Improvement Proposal 361, which would phase out vulnerable signature methods and eventually restrict transactions from wallets that had not upgraded.
Lopp argued that freezing dormant bitcoin could be preferable to allowing future quantum attackers to steal it.
Blockstream CEO Adam Back favored voluntary upgrades, warning against forcing holders to migrate through a predetermined freeze.
Neither approach has been adopted. BIP 361 remains a draft, as does BIP 360, which proposes a new Bitcoin output type designed to reduce exposure to certain quantum attacks.
“Coins that never move are a social problem, not a technical one,” Fan said.
His concern is that developers can introduce new security standards, but they cannot necessarily compel wallet owners to adopt them.
“If the old path stays open forever, attackers will use it,” he said.
Bridges and custody
The same problem affects crypto custodians, which often require multiple parties to approve transactions rather than relying on a single private key. These systems would also need to be changed to support quantum-resistant signatures.
coindesk.com