invezz.com
The European Central Bank (ECB) is pushing hard for the digital euro.
It argues that Europe risks falling behind in the global race for central bank digital currencies (CBDCs).
ECB officials warn that delays in the project could erode Europe’s financial sovereignty, as other countries are advancing quickly with their digital currencies.
What is the ECB’s plan?
The ECB has been exploring the concept of a digital euro since 2021.
ECB President Christine Lagarde has hinted at launching the digital currency by 2027, but progress has been slow.
A key obstacle is the lack of a unified legal framework nearly 17 months after the European Commission’s initial proposal.
The ECB envisions a digital euro that mirrors cash in its privacy and usability.
Offline payments would not share personal data beyond the payer and payee, while online payments would rely on advanced encryption to enhance privacy compared to existing digital payment solutions.
Users could pre-fund their wallets or link them to bank accounts for easy transactions.
However, individual holdings would be capped to prevent destabilization of the banking system.
Why is the digital euro needed?
The ECB argues that the digital euro is crucial for Europe’s financial autonomy.
Thirteen of the eurozone’s 20 countries rely on global payment giants like Visa and Mastercard.
This dependence, the ECB says, makes the eurozone vulnerable to external disruptions.
A digital euro would provide a Europe-wide payment solution, reducing reliance on non-European systems.
Globally, the CBDC race is accelerating.
According to the Bank for International Settlements, 134 countries, representing 98% of the global economy, are exploring CBDCs.
Sixty-six countries are in advanced stages, with nations like China, the Bahamas, and Nigeria already launching CBDCs.
China’s digital yuan has processed $986 billion in transactions by mid-2024, demonstrating its potential to reshape sectors like healthcare and tourism.
The adoption problem
The ECB’s ambition has a big obstacle, that is consumer adoption.
Survey data from the SPACE study shows that many European consumers prefer traditional payment methods like cash and cards.
Introducing a digital euro requires overcoming significant adoption barriers, including consumer habits and perceived complexity.
ECB officials believe the solution lies in design and education.
The digital euro must combine the convenience of cards with the privacy and budgeting benefits of cash.
The ECB considers public awareness campaigns to be essential as well.
Studies show that exposure to new payment methods, such as during the Covid-19 pandemic, can influence long-term behaviour.
Does Europe risk losing the race?
ECB officials worry that Europe is falling behind.
China’s digital yuan is a clear example of the transformative power of CBDCs.
Other countries, including the UK, Singapore, and Australia, are running advanced pilots.
Europe’s fragmented payment systems and slow legislative processes risk sidelining the eurozone in this technological shift.
The truth is that Europe’s lead in CBDC development is at risk without decisive action.
ECB officials believe that the digital euro must be ready when it is needed, reflecting frustration over legislative delays.
Is a digital euro worth the risk?
Despite its promise, the digital euro is faced with skepticism.
First, there is the issue of central bank overreach.
The ECB proposes creating a payment system that competes with commercial banks.
While this could reduce Europe’s reliance on non-European firms, it risks undermining the banking system.
Caps on individual holdings are meant to address this, but they also contradict the ECB’s claim of “freedom and convenience.”
Second, the digital euro might not solve the problems it aims to address.
Europe’s payment landscape is already competitive, with numerous digital options that work well.
Creating a new system from scratch could add complexity rather than simplify payments.
Third, the project highlights deep flaws in the eurozone’s financial architecture. Europe lacks a banking union and centralized deposit insurance.
A digital euro could make matters worse, particularly if national central banks and the ECB clash over its design.
The bigger picture
The ECB’s push for the digital euro is not just about payments.
It highlights a broader struggle for relevance in a digital world.
Central banks, traditionally focused on monetary stability, are now venturing into new territory.
But with this ambition comes the risk of mission creep.
By taking on roles traditionally handled by commercial banks and private firms, the ECB could undermine trust in the financial system it is supposed to safeguard.
The global CBDC race is real, but Europe must decide if winning it is worth the cost.
A poorly executed digital euro could destabilize the banking system and deepen divisions within the EU.
Ultimately, a digital euro is more than a payment tool—it is a gamble on Europe’s financial future.
Whether this gamble pays off depends on how well the ECB addresses the challenges of design, adoption, and integration into Europe’s financial ecosystem.
The post Is the digital euro Europe’s future or a risky distraction? appeared first on Invezz