blockworks.co
The airdrop of first-time governance tokens from Ethereum scaling solution Optimism has gone awry in a major way — thanks to a third-party the collective tapped to provide liquidity.
All told, about 20 million Optimism governance tokens (OP) that were loaned to facilitate transactions were lost, with cryptocurrency market maker Wintermute taking responsibility for the lapse.
The loan was initially deployed on Wintermute’s wallets on Optimism, but Wintermute CEO Evgeny Gaevoy said in a statement that “we made a serious error.”
Here’s what happened: The wallet address Wintermute used to receive the loan was inaccessible, because it relied on Ethereum layer-1 multi-signature technology that had yet to be deployed to Optimism, which runs as a layer-2. A layer-1 is the foundational function of a given blockchain, while layer-2s are built on top, typically to provide new features or liquidity.
A hacker, meanwhile, took advantage of the technological lapse to transfer the 20 million OP tokens from layer-1 to layer-2, even as Wintermute scrambled to recover the in-limbo funds. The attacker, however, had as of publication only liquidated about a million of the stolen tokens.
More important is what they knew and when. They knew about this on May 30th. There was a 15 hour gap between the test transaction of 1 $OP and the following transaction. They didn't notice something was wrong? They knew 1 million was dumped on 6/5. Did exchanges know about this?
— Benjamin Singer (@BenjaminSinger8) June 8, 2022
“L1 is confusing enough for most people to navigate, and L2 brings a new set of paradigms over key management and safety, even for experienced crypto users and teams,” Gaevoy said.
“We are not sure why they chose not to liquidate all of it at once,” Gaevoy said. “There is hope that it is a white hat exploit, in which case the remaining funds are potentially recoverable. However we are currently operating under the premise that it is not the case, since we haven’t received any communication from them and our message on the chain was left unanswered.”
The attacker still owns 19 million OP tokens. Wintermute said the company plans to buy back the tokens once the attacker sells, saying the purchase “can potentially create price volatility in the token,” but that the market maker will “make best efforts to smoothen the effect.”
The Optimism Foundation has not chosen to update its network — likely requiring a hard fork — to halt the movement of stolen OP tokens that have not yet been stolen or sold as the foundation believes that “using centralized control to attempt a partial recovery would set a significant precedent.”
Security flaws and the illicit process of attaining cryptoassets have become a common problem for many platforms, and lawmakers are eager to look for solutions.
It comes down to the hallmark phrase, “Not your keys, not your coins,” Ashton Wolfe, the project lead of Crypto Fight Club, told Blockworks.
“Of course, to protect people’s assets, governments will think that continuously hammering down on regulations will fix this solution,” Wolfe said. “Unfortunately, this still hasn’t worked, because it is a very slow process, and users resent uploading private documents to these counter-parties in order to use the platform.”